The director of the Cave-Turch Road Tigers in Hebei Street: Who is responsible for this violence?

• From street violence to public security case, to question the responsibility of the head of the public security of the Party in the city of Sindh and the city of Bainhu

China's Focused Insight Survey

New City of White Gorge, Boden, Hebei Province, 24 September 2026.

One woman sat down on a wet road and her hair was held tight by another woman in a light-colored shirt. She's down, she's moving with pull, and her hands are trying to resist. There are people around and people are coming forward.

A white Land Rover vehicle was parked next to it.

A video, which lasted 5 minutes and 14 seconds, documented the violent clashes that took place in the streets of the Hebei Cave.

The video presentation was dragged by the local head of the “Good Student Hostage Centre” Chen Xiaojie. The incident occurred during the lunch hours of the school day, as a result of a dispute between the water of the road, the flow of the students and the movement of the vehicles.

Chen Xiaojie stated that she had asked a Land Rover to retreat from her journey in order to allow the students to move safely, and that an altercation between the two sides had occurred, which was then pulled and dragged.

The video also shows the diagnostic certificates of two hospitals and the notification of administrative cases issued by the New City Division of the Public Security Department of the City of Porjun.

46 days have passed since the 24 September incident to 9 November.

However, as of the time of the preparation of the present draft, the publicly verifiable material still did not show how the case was finally handled, whether the persons involved had been subjected to administrative sanctions and whether the procedure for the identification and investigation of injuries had been completed.

Why is it still difficult to find clear conclusions from public information about a conflict in broad daylight, with live images, witnesses, hospital diagnostics and public security documents?

More notably, it is worth asking: Under a system of governance under which the CCPC leads the political and legal work, can the law ensure equal treatment between ordinary and economically powerful people when they are in conflict? If there is an attempt to influence cases by relying on wealth, relationships or even public power, can existing oversight mechanisms be detected and prevented in a timely manner?

I. Passage from student to street: What happened?

The Cave is a well-known Chinese container industry, with a large number of shops, processing enterprises and operators.

On 24 September, at around 11.50 p.m., students were on the road near a holding centre in Caucasian Trench, where they were leaving school.

According to Chen Xiaojie, there was water on the road and temporary water-shelter facilities were set up to avoid the children being wet by the way.

At that point, a Land Rover vehicle came.

Chen Xiaojie stated that the vehicle had been pressurized and she hoped that the driver would back down and allow the children to move safely.

A traffic dispute that could have been resolved through communication had then become a conflict of words.

Chen Xiaojie recalled that the other party had not only refused to give up, but had also committed verbal abuse. After further escalation of the dispute, she was caught in the hair and eventually fell on the ground.

The live footage at the beginning of the video showed a woman sitting on the road while another woman grabbed her hair and was working backwards. There was a crowd of people who were there to discourage and pull.

Such a seizure of hair and physical pressure on others is beyond the scope of normal disputes.

The video also featured two interviewed parents who gave separate accounts of what they had seen. One of them indicated that he saw someone holding his hair, pressing it to the ground and dragging it.

The personal accounts, parental testimony and some live videos of Chen Xiaojie have in fact given mutual evidence of the key to scratching and dragging.

A person can disagree with another person ' s request and argue for the right to road passage, but this cannot be a means of forcing the other to submit through violence.

This line should not have changed by driving what car, how much wealth or who knows.

. Hospital diagnosis, public security case: after injury has entered legal process

After the conflict, Chen Xiaojie was given a medical examination.

The video shows the diagnosis materials of the local hospital in the White Hollow, which documented symptoms associated with brain trauma, multiple shallow injuries, etc.

Another medical certificate from the University of Hebei hospital included various injuries to the body, chest injuries, facial injuries and injuries to the upper left limb.

These medical materials are currently based on video presentation versions and have not yet been independently validated in full.

But this incident did not stop at the online exposure stage.

The video shows that the City of Por Din City Public Security Bureau, the White Cane New City Branch, issued an administrative case notification, in which it was officially filed against the alleged assault reported on 24 September.

This means that the local public security organs have initiated administrative investigation procedures.

Under the Revised Law of the People ' s Republic of China on the Punishment of Public Security Administration, which was in force since 1 January 2026, public security organs shall, in principle, settle cases of public security within 30 days of the date on which they are to be considered as self-sufficient. In cases of major, complex cases, the time limit may be extended by approval; The legal period for the identification and hearing of cases is not counted against the time limit for the proceedings.

As at 9 November, 46 days had elapsed since the incident.

What investigations have been completed by the New City Public Security Bureau in White Cane for the last 46 days?

Is the injury certificate activated? Is the full surveillance available? Are witnesses being questioned? Were the drivers involved and other participants investigated? If the case is not closed, is there a legal extension or validation procedure?

These issues should have been clearly explained through the procedure of informing the parties in the regulated case.

The absence of public outcome does not mean that it is possible to conclude that the public security organs have not dealt with the case, let alone to prove directly that someone has been sheltered.

However, the continuing lack of clear information on the handling of an open conflict that has entered the administrative process is itself a matter of concern for society.

iii. Who is in charge of the social security of the White Hole? From the police station to the City Council

The new city of White Dynasty is not a place where the responsibility for the land can be blurred.

There are PSI, the Control Committee and the Public Security Sub-Directorate, with the superiors being the corresponding party and public security organs in the city of Pública.

The incident cannot be a mere question of who did it on the ground, but also of the relevant agencies with policing and oversight responsibilities.

According to the public information:

Sun Gin Gang, New City Public Security Bureau, White Goug.

The SONG Jing Gang was previously listed as a member of the White Goose Party Labour Committee, as a party secretary and as a director of the Public Security Division. As the latest 2026 confirmation of appointment has not yet been obtained, the current Director-General remains to be based on an official local directory.

Whoever is currently in charge, the Public Security Directorate of New City in White Cane is the filing authority listed in the video " Information on Administrative Cases ".

Shuikou New City Party Labour Committee: Liu Xiaomei.

According to public reports in 2025, Liu Xiaomei was the Secretary and Director of the New City Party Labour Committee in White Gorge. She then made social security and stability one of her local priorities. Its latest incumbency situation still required further confirmation.

As the party political governing body in the local governance system, the White Canyon Party Labour Committee and the Control Committee should be concerned about any gaps in public security management and whether the relevant administrative bodies are functioning in accordance with the law.

Púdigo City Public Security Bureau: Takafei.

Publicly available information on appointments and dismissals indicates that Gao flew to the post of Deputy Mayor of the City of Presidencies and head of the Municipal Public Security Department in January 2026.

As the principal head of the higher public security organs, the municipal public security bureaus headed by Gao Fei have the corresponding responsibilities of directing public security operations and monitoring law enforcement.

The Political and Legal Commission of the City of Validation: Sun Faifeng.

The public information lists Sun Faifeng as the Secretary of the Standing Committee of the PSMC and the Political Law Commission. In August 2026, he was re-elected to the Standing Committee of the Commission of the Pre-City of the Pre-City.

The Commission is responsible for the leadership of the Political Committee and for the coordination and harmonization of political and legal matters, but it cannot substitute for the public security organs in making specific administrative decisions, let alone interfere in the process of the independent conduct of cases in accordance with the law.

Preserve City Council: Zhao Wenzhen.

On 20 August 2026, Zhao Wenbei was elected Secretary of the CPC.

These names are not randomly labelled as liability. The existence of a personal failure, ultra vires intervention or other disciplinary violations must be linked to specific duties and conduct.

However, the public has the right to ask the authorities to answer:

• New City Public Security Bureau, White Hole: is the case closed? If not, what are the reasons and the legal procedures?
• Zinhu New City Party Labour Committee, Management Committee: Is there a problem with the security and security management of students near the Trust Centre that needs to be overhauled?
• The Public Security Bureau of the City of Valdified: Are there legal oversight of the process of processing cases and any procedural or enforcement problems identified?

- Commission on Political and Law of the Municipal Council and the Municipal Council: How can institutional responsibility for the fair administration of justice, grass-roots governance and social stability be enforced?

Security incidents occurring in the territories do not mean that all leadership cadres are held accountable for personal violence; However, the statutory duty cannot be excluded from public scrutiny because the problem is on the street.

IV. The previous day emphasized the rule of law, and the next day street violence

There is also a time-frame for this incident to be noted.

On 22 September 2026, the Secretary of the City Council of the City of Paul Zhao Wenzhu hosted a learning session of the City Council Centre for Theory Learning on the theme of rule of law.

According to a public report in the Daily Press of 23 September, the meeting emphasized learning to follow up on Xi Jinping ' s rule of law philosophy and accelerate the building of higher levels of rule of law protection.

Sun Fai Fu Fue, Ko Fei and others also participated in the meeting and made an exchange of views.

One day later, on 24 September, this street clash was illustrated by video in the new city of White Gorge.

There is no proven causal link between the two matters, but a realistic contrast that deserves to be examined.

Official meetings can place constant emphasis on legal governance, fair justice and social stability.

But the rule of law that is truly felt by ordinary people is not in the speeches of the Conference, but in the specifics that happen every day.

When the children crossed the street, when someone was caught with their hair dragged, when the injured person was reported to the police with a medical certificate, and after the case was received by the public security authorities.

The effectiveness of the rule of law ultimately depends on the equal protection of a common person without special status and on the prompt and fair treatment of violations.

This is also a governance issue for the governing bodies of the Porporates.

V. Social questions behind a Rover: Can wealth be treated differently?

In the video, a white Land Rover vehicle was very visible.

Luxury cars are not uncommon in a place such as the White Gap, where business is active and wealth-generating.

The fact that cars are expensive does not mean that the driver necessarily has a political background, let alone the vehicle model, can be judged to be able to influence the public security organs.

But in this video, the parallel of the car and the street grabs is still raising a serious social issue:

Why do people fear that in some public conflicts the rich and connected people will receive special treatment more easily than the average?

This concern relates to the basic trust of society in power and law.

If ordinary people believe that the economic conditions, social status or personal ties of the parties after a dispute have arisen may affect the way in which the law enforcement agencies deal with the case, then the principle of equality before the law is in danger of a crisis of trust.

If one believes that, if one is strong enough to force others to give in by verbal abuse, intimidation or even violence, the first to be violated is the most basic equality between human beings.

This is not a crime of wealth itself.

What is really needed is to treat wealth as power, power as privilege and privilege as a justification for strangulation.

In this case, the existence of a relationship of exploitation affecting the administration of justice and the existence of undue pressure have not yet been confirmed.

But “the presence of power” should be a matter of clear scrutiny of case procedures, rather than being ignored.

The investigation should be able to indicate whether there was undue external interference in the case. Are there procedural requirements? Are all parties subject to the same legal standard?

If not, the result of the case should be a response to social misgivings.

Where they do exist, the specific intervener and the relevant persons should be further held accountable.

. The CCP-led system of governance, which must answer how power is bound

The deep-seated problems raised by the white ditch events are not just acts of violence by individuals.

It also concerns how effective responsibilities are established between the party leadership, executive law enforcement and public oversight in China ' s current system of governance.

Under the leadership of the Communist Party of China, the political and legal system has assumed responsibility for the maintenance of social order, the protection of the legitimate rights and interests of citizens and the legal treatment of offences and offences.

However, the ability of a system to win social confidence depends not only on what principles it proclaims, but also more on how it binds those in power.

Equity is very specific for ordinary people.

(b) Those who have money are guilty of offences and shall be dealt with in accordance with the law; (b) The person who is entitled to violate the law and should be dealt with in accordance with the law; Persons without background are also subject to effective protection.

When cases are not clearly explained for a long time, it is natural for the public to be concerned whether the investigation process is not completed, whether there is a problem with administrative efficiency or whether there is undue interference.

These possibilities cannot be confused.

However, it is the duty of the relevant authorities to remove as much as possible public concern about improper interference with power by acting in accordance with the law, by informing and being monitored in a timely manner.

Power is monitored, not as a breach of the order of governance, but as a necessary condition for ordinary people to believe that the law can protect themselves.

A truly effective system of social governance cannot require ordinary people to have the opportunity to make their experiences heard only after they have access to video, media and online attention.

Otherwise, cameras may gradually become an important basis for people to protect their rights, and cyber-exposure may be used as an additional means of facilitating problem resolution.

But not every person who suffers from injustice has a camera, nor does every person injured have access to social attention.

Unrecorded, undistributed injuries also require legal protection.

What exactly is left on the streets of the Caves after seven or 46 days?

Finally, Chen Xiaojie ' s husband, Liu Hanway, spoke to the camera and he was initially afraid to see the full picture of his wife in conflict.

When he finally saw the scene of his wife being pulled and dragged, it remained difficult to calm.

For the family, this is not an abstract social issue, but an experience of an ordinary person being harmed in a familiar street.

As the conflict has erupted, the problem of crossing by students has been replaced by more serious physical security problems.

The injured went to the hospital, the family was interviewed and the police filed a case.

But the problem left by this incident should not end with a written notification.

What exactly are the legal responsibilities of the personnel involved? Are the injured provided with the necessary relief? Has the public security organs completed their investigation? Has anyone attempted to influence the administration of justice through social relations?

These issues concern the rights of the parties and the trust of society in the rule of law.

The public and regulated exercise of their respective responsibilities is the most effective way of responding to social doubts for the White Cane public security organs, the local party political and political authorities and the relevant departments of the city responsible for public security and law and order.

For Chinese society, the deeper question posed by this conflict is whether wealth and power can be bound by fair rules.

A city can have a large market, a prosperous business and expensive cars.

But the most important public order in a society is not how many people a powerful person can give in to, but everyone knows that they have the right to be free from violence and to be able to deal with them in accordance with the law.

From the wet street of the Hebei Cave to the party and public security organs of the city of Paul, the incident should be followed up not only by one person ' s violence, but also by the law ' s ability to maintain the same standards of wealth, identity and social relations.

46 days later, the open information still does not provide a complete answer.

The answer cannot be found by the injured person alone.

It should come from public bodies that have investigative, prosecutorial and supervisory responsibilities under the law.

• I'm sorry.

Information and interview notes

The draft is based on a video of the events in the Hebei Baik ditch street, which is 5 minutes and 14 seconds long and contains live videos, Chen Xiaojie ' s statement, two parents ' statements, hospital diagnostics, a public security administrative case case case case-in-chief and family interviews. The fact-finding statements in the video are distinguished from what can be directly confirmed in the image. The draft did not make an unsubstantiated finding as to the identity of the person concerned, the outcome of the final punishment or whether a public official had intervened in the case.

Publicly available:

• New City Council and Zhao Wen-sai were elected to report in

2026.

• Report on the Law Building Learning Conference of the Preservative City Council on 22 September 2026
• Report from Hebei University on the head of the Public Security Department of the city of Paul.
• People ' s Network report on the leadership of the New City Party Labour Committee and local development in White Cane
• Law of the People ' s Republic of China on Administrative Punishments for Security (revised in 2025)