The 39-year-old man, Guo Xian (alias), who works in the Shenzhen City of Guangdong for the purpose of web-based services, has been exhausted in the past three years by a case of a casino-opening crime.

The case was handled by the Public Security Directorate of the Hot Spring District of the Autonomous Region of Xinjiang, Bortara Mongolia (hereinafter referred to as Bo region) which is more than 4,800 kilometres from the same region.

In April 2025, at first instance, in the face of the crime of opening casinos across territories that could not be proved by a “casino”, the District Court of the Springs held that the case was one of expansion of jurisdiction and the creation of a link to jurisdiction. Also, on the grounds that the case is susceptible to being challenged as “off-water fishing”, a passive situation that would have a significant negative impact on the credibility of the law enforcement system in the Spring County Public Prosecutor's Office, it is recommended that the Prosecutor's Office of Spring County withdraw the charges.

Following a letter of refusal from the Prosecutor ' s Office of Spa County, the Spa County Court convicted the suspect on 22 August 2025 and sentenced all 11 defendants to suspended sentences and fines.

Casinos over 4,800 km: Seine Sanctuary Police has been controversial and has returned to re-trial, with 7 persons not prosecuted

The Xinjiang Springs County Public Security Bureau has handled the case

Following an appeal by 11 accused, the Bo County Court of Justice reversed the original judgement on 5 February of this year and remanded it for lack of clarity and insufficient evidence.

During the retrial, the Seng Spring District Prosecutor's Office withdrew the charges to the court on the basis that the seven defendants were “other persons who should not be held criminally liable” for the crimes provided for by law. The seven defendants who withdrew their indictments were also given a decision of relative non-indictment on the grounds that “the crime was minor, contained a guilty plea, an active retort, etc., and did not require a sentence”. The prosecution was subsequently pursued on 23 October, after a decision was taken to change the indictment against four others, including Peace Guo.

Before the reopening of the first trial on 19 November, counsel for the remaining accused found that the investigating officer's wife, Bachumi, was a judge of the second instance in the case and that she had participated in the first trial of the case. The defence claimed that the “husband's wife in the case” had been asked to recuse the judge. The composition of the Full Court was changed by the Spa County Court on 16 November, as the defence argued.

01

Standings of more than 4,800 kilometres.

The safety of Guo, who has been in the home for over two years, has been trying to find a stable job, but the background check of the target company at the time of his job search shows that he has an outstanding criminal case, which has left him without work.

Prior to the incident, he was an employee of Shenzhen City Magic Technology Company Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as Magic Corporation), which was responsible for the technical maintenance of several live platforms on a daily basis. This has allowed him to stabilize his income at tens of thousands per month.

However, his life changed after he was arrested in Shenzhen on 23 December 2023 by the Sengquan County Public Security Department officers on suspicion of opening a casino. The map shows that the Springs County Public Security Bureau is more than 4,800 kilometres from Shenzhen City, where Guo lives peacefully.

After the trial, he learned from the court that, while he was arrested, 10 individuals from other companies associated with his work, including one of the following, Zeng, Chen, Xiaoming, Lee and Zhang, were arrested or surrendered to the police station of the Sengquan County.

The case registration form and the decision to file the case at the Spring Spring County Public Security Directorate confirmed that Mr. Guo and others had been arrested, based on a lead from Duman Bei, a local citizen of the Spring County, who had reported to the public security authorities on 1 June 2023, and that a web page called Victory Sports was suspected of gambling on the Internet. On the date of the report, the Spa County Public Security Bureau decided to open a case for investigation.

From the report, the defence counsel found that the “winning game APP” time was “cross-crossing” in the evidence received by the Sengquan County Public Security Directorate on 1 June, when it was admitted. As the API intercepts provided by the source showed that they were fully loaded and placed on 8 June 2023, a week had passed before the submission of the report on 1 June.

Casinos over 4,800 km: Seine Sanctuary Police has been controversial and has returned to re-trial, with 7 persons not prosecuted

Evidence submitted by Duman Bei of the 1 June 2023 report, with full value on 8 June 2023 (Red Circle)

After the conclusion of the police investigation, the Spa County Prosecutor ' s Office filed a public indictment in this case with the Spa County Court on 22 January 2025.

The office of the Prosecutor of the State of Sengquan County charged that in 2018 Chen Jai (alias, fugitive) had recruited the accused, ex-Sang Guo, Chen Cho, Tsang, Zhang Chi, Sing Ho Ming, Hon Hoyang, Lee Chi Ning and others to participate in the Philippine company Manila, to develop chatting (a chat-making software developed by the gambling platform) and the Wang Sports Live platform (a live sports platform to guide the gambling website).

In July 2019, the accused, Jean Guo, Chen and others, returned to the Shenzhen City of Shenzhen City, to work at Rongkang Information Technology Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as Shenzhen Lukang Corporation) under the arrangement of Chen Kae, in view of the need for continuous updating and maintenance of the live chat platform, which is a matter of lack of technical skills in the Philippines.

At the end of 2019, five companies were established by Chen Shui-Chai staff because of their corporate development needs. Among them, Li Mining led the research and development team for the Black and White Lives to establish Shenzhen City Tide Cultural Media Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as the Tide-Color Company); (a) The R & D team led by Hon. Ioyang led by Wang's Sports Lives established Changhua Information Technology Ltd., Shenzhen City (hereinafter referred to as Changhua Corporation); The accused, Chen Jie, led the SEO team to establish Shenzhen City Micro-Stamp Cultural Media Ltd. (hereinafter called MicroStamps Inc.); Zhang led the chat team on the establishment of Shenzhen City Sam Jie-Technology Ltd (hereinafter referred to as Sen Zheng Corporation); One of the authors was in charge of the Dolphin live broadcast and the development of the GOAL platform at Longkang.

Chen Ka is the owner of the Philippines Manila Company, the owner of the Rongkang Company, Changhua Corporation, the Tide-Cals, Sen Jia Corporation, Micro-Fest Corporation and Magic Corporation in Shenzhen City.

Since 2018, Chen Kae has signed profit-sharing agreements with the owners of the gaming platform, Huan Bai, Victory and JB, and led the team in developing the chat, the King's Sports Live, the Dolphin Live, and the Black and White Live to channel the gambling website.

The Public Prosecution Service stated that the acts of Mr. Guo, Mr. Chen and others, who knowingly committed gambling, provided them with software development, technical support and live transmission, were in violation of article 303, paragraph 2, of the Criminal Code, which provides that the facts of the offence were clear and that the evidence was sufficient and that criminal liability should be established for the offence of opening a casino.

Defence counsel indicated that the “winner sports” referred to by the source had no connection to the companies, platforms and live software developed by all the accused.

The defendant company developed live platform and chat software and was not responsible for the operation of the platform and software, and was led by the platform's operators and the anchors hired by the platform to operate and directly to the “gay site” by means of embedded links and mouthcasts.

According to Article 4 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate on the Specific Application of the Law in Criminal Cases of Gambling: “ An accomplice to gambling offences who, knowing that others commit gambling offences, provides them with direct assistance with funds, computer networks, communications, cost settlement, etc. is punished with gambling offences. The blogger adds:

Counsel indicated that “know” and “direct assistance” were two essential conditions that constituted an accomplice. However, the accused in this case acted only to develop communication tools (live platform, chatting software) and not to “directly help” gambling websites.

At the same time, the Supreme Law, the Supreme Prosecutor and the relevant legal provisions of the Ministry of Public Security on offences of online gambling and on the handling of offences of cross-border gambling have also made clear the “helping behaviour”, which refers to the provision of assistance to “gaming websites”, namely “direct help”.

Thus, even if there was a gambling offence at “winner sports”, the accused in the present case should not be prosecuted.

02

The court of first instance considered the extension of jurisdiction and recommended that the prosecution withdraw its case

Mr. Guo and others indicated to the author that at the pre-court meeting of the Spring County Court on 12 March 2025, the defence challenged the jurisdiction of the case before the Full Court, holding that the Spring County Court had no jurisdiction in the case.

The Spa County Court examined the case and stated that the investigating authorities had considered the Spa County to have jurisdiction by means of a cyber gambling act conducted by the reporting person, Duman Bei, in Spa County through a mobile phone, and that there was a problem of expanding jurisdiction to create a link to the jurisdiction.

The Spa County Court held that the reference to “place of crime” was intended to make it clear that “act” constituted a crime; The second is to make it clear that the accused is in this case. In this case, Duman Bei was the whistleblower and was not considered an offence to participate in cyber gambling, nor was it the defendant in the present case, so that the “place where the gambler committed the Internet gambling” rule was not applied.

The accused in this case, Mr. Guo, Mr. Chen, Mr. Zhang, Mr. Zhang, Mr. Guo, Mr. Zhang, Mr. Zhang, Mr. Zhenhein, Mr. Zhenhein, Mr. Zhenxi, Mr. Zhenxi, Mr. Zhenxi, Mr. Zhenxi, Mr. Zhenxi, Mr. Zhenxi, Mr. Zhenxi, Mr. Zhenxi, Mr. Zhenxi, Mr. Zhenxi, Mr. Zhenxi, Mr. Zhang, Mr. Zhenxi, Mr. Zhenxi, Mr. Zhang, Mr. Zhang, Mr. Zhang, Mr. Zhang, Mr. Xue, Mr. Zhu Zhuiqi, Mr. Zhu, Mr. Zhu Zhu, Mr. Zhu, Mr. Zhu, Mr. Zhujibo, Mr. Zhu Zhu, Mr.

The Spaqua County Court also stated that the case involved the trans-territorial handling of the offence of opening casinos, involving 11 accused and 15 defence counsel. Upon enquiry, the accused lived in Shenzhen, Shandong, Yanta and Hunan, among others, and could be challenged as “extra-territorial” “enforcement of law” and “contribution of law” in the context of procedural irregularities such as lack of jurisdiction. If the accused or the defence in this case were to make an online statement in response to the case, it would have had a very, very negative impact on the credibility of the Spa County Public Prosecution System.

On 1 April 2025, the Spa County Court issued a Recommendation on Withdrawal of Indictments to the Spa District Prosecutor ' s Office, recommending that the prosecution withdraw the indictment.

Casinos over 4,800 km: Seine Sanctuary Police has been controversial and has returned to re-trial, with 7 persons not prosecuted

The Spa County Court recommended that the prosecution withdraw its case, arguing that procedural irregularities such as lack of jurisdiction could easily be challenged as “profit enforcement” for “off-sea fishing”

A week later, the Spa County Prosecutor ' s Office replied that the court ' s recommendation to dismiss the case was not sufficiently justified.

The reasons for this are, first, that “crimes” include the location of the gambling website server, the place where the gambler is engaged in cyber gambling. The gambling officer, Duman Bey, who was a confidant, was visiting the relevant gambling website and making online gambling in the Hot Springs District District, where the gambler was engaged in online gambling.

Secondly, the jurisdiction of the public security organs to investigate offences of cyber gambling across regions is disputed and should be resolved in good faith and in accordance with the principles that facilitate the investigation of the facts of the crime and facilitate the prosecution. If no agreement can be reached after consultation, the superior public security organ of the common press shall designate its jurisdiction. The Supreme Law of the Ministry of Public Security and the Supreme Public Prosecutor may, if necessary, designate jurisdiction over cases of major online gambling that are about to be closed in the province. The case was assigned to the Public Security Directorate of Bo County by the Public Security Directorate of the Hot Spring District, and the competent public security organs did not raise the relevant jurisdictional objections and there was no jurisdictional dispute.

Thirdly, the place of cross-border cyber gambling offences includes the location of servers used for network services used to commit gambling offences, the location of network service providers, the location of network information systems used by suspects, gamblers, and the place where suspects assist in the commission of cyber gambling offences. The location of the web-based information system applicable to the particular betttler, Duman Bei, is in the Hot Springs County.

Fourth, the case was initially investigated by the Seng Spring County Public Security Directorate, which did not raise a jurisdictional objection when it opened the case and then went to the relevant competent public security organ to assist in the investigation of the evidence.

The Hot Spring District Prosecutor ' s Office has recommended that the Hot Spring District Court resolve jurisdictional challenges and procedural matters in accordance with the law.

03

Casino could not confirm that 11 defendants were all suspended.

The defence of the vast majority of the accused is not guilty of charges against the Public Prosecution Service. They submit, first, that there is insufficient objective evidence of the existence of gambling websites, the elements of gambling projects, gambling, gambling and related funds, and that the evidence in the present case does not prove that the sites in question are gambling sites.

Secondly, the evidence in this case lacks evidence that the website was linked to the gambling website and profited from the gambling site.

Lastly, the persons involved had no subjective intent to open a casino. The conditions required for the offence of opening a casino include, first, knowing that the act of opening a casino using a website is being carried out upstream; The second is the existence of a intentional link with the predicate offender and the subjective intention to commit the offence of opening a casino.

The defence also stated that the “crime of opening a casino” was first to prove the existence of a “casino”, which in the present case was not a physical space but rather a gambling website.

It was noted that in the present case, the investigative authorities had used remote surveys to prove that the website was a gambling site.

The public prosecution has produced notes of surveys, inspections and investigations, which confirm that, by surveying the link to winning sports, the website shows that “winner sports” are merged with “Leton sports”, called “Leton sports”, and that the site is surveyed through the corresponding link to “talking about the treasure” “King Dolphin sports”, suspected of being a gambling site, which contains gambling projects such as sports, real people, lottery tickets, electronics, chess cards, etc.

Casinos over 4,800 km: Seine Sanctuary Police has been controversial and has returned to re-trial, with 7 persons not prosecuted

Criminal Judgment at First Instance, Police Survey results show that the site was suspected of gambling

The defence considers that the term “suspect” in itself has made it clear that the investigative authorities cannot determine the legal nature of these sites by technical means. “If not even the investigative authorities are able to determine, how can the court determine on that basis? Moreover, the cut-off chart attached to the examination notes shows that the “talking of the Queen's Sports” “live-live river dolphins” — i.e., the platform that the accused was accused of developing did not contain any gambling items such as sports, real people, lottery tickets, chess cards, etc. — and examined the error of the examination.

In addition, one of the central facts alleged by the Public Prosecution Service

  • since 2018, Chen Kae has signed a profit-sharing agreement with the owner of the gambling platform and led the team in developing a live platform to channel the gambling website. This fact, if established, means that the company involved is not a mere technical service provider, but rather a profit-sharing relationship with gambling websites. This is the key to the identification of “co-management” of casinos rather than “provision of neutral technical services”.

The defence indicated that none of these agreements were in the case file. The defence repeatedly requested the Public Prosecution Service to produce a “profit-sharing agreement” during the hearing, but the prosecution failed to submit relevant material or to provide a consistent statement of whether the agreement existed.

I note that there is one more detail to note. On the night of the crime, the removal of computer hard drives by some of the accused was used as a basis for the presumption of “knowledge” in the first instance judgement.

However, the case ' s Electronic Data Check Notes showed that the seized hard drives, although extracted, did not examine their actual content and were not presented to the Tribunal. To the accused ' s knowledge, there is nothing in it that relates to gambling offences.

Counsel also stated that there was a problem of a broken chain of evidence in the case. For example, the “winner sports” referred to by the source have no evidence of being drawn from the “kings' sports”; The live platforms served by several of the anchors involved (ex-accused in this case and several others) have no evidence of being identical to the live platforms developed by the accused, and the original defence of the first instance submitted evidence of a very large number of sites of the same name when the search for “Kings Sports” and “Dolphin Live” was conducted.

The remote survey of the live platform, chatting, is a web site provided by the “gamper” and there is no evidence that it is identical to the live platform developed by the accused. The live platform developed by the accused, the chatting of treasures, was not extracted and examined for analysis at all.

In this context, the first instance judgement of the Seng Spring County Court found that 11 persons, including Guo Seong and Chen, who served gambling platforms for profit, had committed acts that constituted the offence of opening casinos and were punishable by law.

In the present case, the Spa County Court found that the defendant had formed a company to become a core manager, developed a live platform for gambling, provided software development, technical support, etc., and received a fixed monthly wage, without any indication of the legal origin of the salary, and should be considered to have earned the illegals. The defence argument that the salaries of the accused, Mr. Guo and others, cannot be considered as proceeds of an offence is inadmissible.

The defence maintains that in criminal proceedings, the burden of proof of the guilt of the accused rests with the Public Prosecution Service. The Public Prosecution Service's assertion that the salary is the proceeds of an offence should be proven, and the accused cannot be required to “state the lawful source”. When the accused is unable to account for it, the accused is presumed to have earned the wrong — again, the breach reverses the burden of proof.

In the end, the Spring County Court adopted the view of the Hot Spring District Prosecutor ' s Office that the gambling officer, Duman Bei, was located in the Hot Spring County where the information network system used by a particular garment was located and that the Hot Spring County Public Security Bureau was investigating the prosecution and the Hot Spring District Prosecutor ' s Office was examining the case, and that the House had jurisdiction.

On 22 August 2025, the Spa County Court handed down its first instance judgement. Eleven defendants were convicted of the offence of opening casinos, all of them sentenced to suspended sentences ranging from one to two years and six months, and to fines ranging from $20,000 to $50,000.

04

All 11 defendants appealed and 7 were not indicted upon remand

After the first instance judgement, 11 defendants, all of whom were sentenced to suspended sentences, appealed the verdict to the Bo Central Court.

After hearing the court of Bo County, which found that the original judgement was not clear and sufficiently substantiated, the court decided on 5 February to quash the first instance judgement and remand the case.

Casinos over 4,800 km: Seine Sanctuary Police has been controversial and has returned to re-trial, with 7 persons not prosecuted

The Court of Justice of Bo County found the original judgement to be unclear and insufficient evidence and decided to remand the cassation judgement.

The defence informed the author that, after the case was remanded, the Prosecutor of the Sengquan County District had replaced the running prosecutor, but the prosecutor, together with the security officers, had travelled to the accused ' s residence to demand that they plead guilty and that they should be reimbursed for the damages.

They consider that instead of re-examining the facts and the evidentiary basis of the case, the prosecution authorities have continued to promote guilty pleas by jointly conducting a case with the public security organs, which could well result in the emptiness of the procedural functions of the retrial.

During the remand, the Sengquan County Prosecutor's Office engaged the Xinjiang Police Academy's Judicial Accreditation Centre to produce a test analysis, stating that the four websites Huambo Sports, Musical Sports, Gaborg Sports and Victory Sports “have the function of a gambling website platform and are compatible with the characteristics of the gambling website. The blogger adds:

The defenders stated that four websites, such as Huambo Sports, were not exactly the subject of technical services from the companies where the accused were located. The examination and analysis of the Wambo sports site referred to may not be a match in itself with the technical services provided by the accused.

But there are some good signs.

On 4 and 5 August this year, the Spa County Court organized a pre-trial meeting on the retrial of the case. At the pre-trial meeting, the defence communicated with the Prosecutor ' s Office of the Spring County on procedural irregularities in the case, the nature of the case, and the question of evidence.

The Spa Public Prosecutor's Office withdrew charges against seven of the defendants after the pre-court meeting at the trial trial in the first instance on the grounds that “other criminal responsibility should not be pursued”.

On the same day, the Prosecutor's Office of Seng Spring County decided to withdraw the charges against seven defendants on the grounds that the offences were minor, contained guilty pleas, positive reversals, etc., and did not require a sentence”.

Counsel states that there was no change in the evidence in the case at that time. In other words, the Spa Public Prosecutor ' s Office should have decided not to prosecute legally or in doubt, after withdrawing the charges on the grounds that seven defendants did not commit crimes; On the other hand, the Public Prosecutor ' s Office decided to take a decision of relative non-indictment on the grounds that the existence of the seven defendants did not require a sentence, which clearly conflicted with factual findings and the application of the law.

In his self-statement, Zhang indicated that he was still being prosecuted on 10 October of this year for not agreeing to the Spa County Court Judge Bainghua “can he make a few payments to refund the damage”.

The defence indicated that, according to the notice received, the first hearing in the case would commence on 19 November. They found, however, that the presiding judge Bainghua had participated in the original part of the first instance in the case.

At the same time, Judge Baeing, the spouse of the C.O., was the core investigator in the case and participated in a large number of investigative evidence in the case. After the case was remanded, it also issued an excessive Information Note at the request of the Hot Spring District Prosecutor ' s Office.

The defence states that during the pre-conference meeting before the first instance court in this case, they asked Bainghua to prove whether any direct relatives had been involved in the investigation of the case, and that the latter had properly explained to the Full Court, the accused and the defence the relationship with Ai-i.

The defence then asked the Baring flower to avoid the case. The District Court of Sparing issued a Notice of Change in the Composition of the Full Court on 16 November, replacing the Baring flower with a different judge.

Casinos over 4,800 km: Seine Sanctuary Police has been controversial and has returned to re-trial, with 7 persons not prosecuted

On the eve of the retrial, the judge Bainghua was replaced on the defence ' s application for recusal

The defence submits that the Central Orders have recently banned “off-sea fishing” and “consumable law enforcement” and that it is undeniable that in the present case, the Public Security Directorate of Squires has established a jurisdictional link through a mobile phone AP-charted screen of the residents of the district, and that there have been cases of “cross-the-border” receipt of evidence of the reported incident.

The ensuing series of investigative activities have also amply confirmed that it is in “consumable law enforcement” in “sea-fishing” and “fishing” from the north-west to south-east of the country, the “marine fishing cases of the farthest distance” and that failure to address the law, to resolutely correct jurisdictional errors and to firmly discourage law enforcement is clearly a reaction to the highest instructions of the central Government to protect the private economy and to follow the law.

Casinos over 4,800 km: Seine Sanctuary Police has been controversial and has returned to re-trial, with 7 persons not prosecuted

** Beijing University Director reported 3.6 million bribes for irregular admission to school, and I did not respond.**

** Huxpei's representative is carrying out more than 300 million projects like "Crunch" and the last kilometre is blocked again**

** Foreign investment lost Ningxia and transferred shares were awarded new obligations after three years**

** Why is the “pants” sentenced to death? ** The present report was submitted after the deadline of 1 July 2007.

**Shangdong 12 million original coal “Zero Buy” exception: criminal civil action is not available**

Casinos over 4,800 km: Seine Sanctuary Police has been controversial and has returned to re-trial, with 7 persons not prosecuted

Original source

Original title
新疆温泉警方跨越4800公里办理的开设赌场案发回重审,11名被告人7人已不起诉
Original author
刘虎
Source account / outlet
微信公众号“法与情”
Originally published
2026-11-18 21:30
Content treatment
Republished
Original article
View original ↗
Published by China Focus
会员发布